Wikipedia / Entanglement distillation
Wikipedia / Entanglement distillation
Entanglement distillation (also called entanglement purification) is the transformation of N copies of an arbitrary entangled state into some number of approximately pure Bell pairs, using only local operations and classical communication. Entanglement distillation can overcome the degenerative influence of noisy quantum channels by transforming previously shared, less-entangled pairs into a smaller number of maximally-entangled pairs.
History
The limits for entanglement dilution and distillation are due to C. H. Bennett, H. Bernstein, S. Popescu, and B. Schumacher, who presented the first distillation protocols for pure states in 1996; entanglement distillation protocols for mixed statess were introduced by Bennett, Gilles Brassard, Popescu, Schumacher, John A. Smolin and William Wootters the same year. Bennett, David DiVincenzo, Smolin and Wootters established the connection to quantum error-correction in a ground-breaking paper published in August 1996, also in the journal of Physical Review, which has stimulated a lot of subsequent research.
Motivation
Suppose that two parties, Alice and Bob, would like to communicate classical information over a noisy quantum channel. Either classical or quantum information can be transmitted over a quantum channel by encoding the information in a quantum state. With this knowledge, Alice encodes the classical information that she intends to send to Bob in a (quantum) product state, as a tensor product of reduced density matrices.
.
The problem that Alice and Bob now face is that quantum communication over large distances depends upon successful distribution of highly entangled quantum states Bell pairs, using only local operations and classical communication. The objective is to share strongly correlated qubits between distant parties (Alice and Bob) in order to allow reliable quantum teleportation or quantum cryptography.
Entanglement entropy
Entanglement entropy quantifies entanglement. Several different definitions have been proposed.
Von Neumann entropy
The von Neumann entropy is a measure of the "quantum uncertainty" or "quantum randomness" associated with a quantum state, analogous to the concept of Shannon entropy in classical information theory.) have a von Neumann entropy of 0. In pure states, there is no uncertainty about the system's state. Mixed states (e.g., probabilistic mixtures of pure states) have a positive entropy value, reflecting an inherent uncertainty in the system's state.
is defined as:
denotes the trace operation, summing over the diagonal elements of a matrix.
. It is widely used in quantum information theory to study entanglement, quantum thermodynamics, and the coherence of quantum systems.
Rényi entanglement entropy
Rényi entropy, which adjusts the sensitivity of the entropy measure to different probabilities.
is defined as:
.
emphasizing high-probability events. Rényi entropy is often used in contexts such as fractal dimensions, signal processing, and statistical mechanics, where a flexible measure of uncertainty or diversity is useful.
As an example of Renyi entropy, a two qubit
. The normalization condition guarantees that the sum of the probabilities add up to 1, meaning that upon measurement, one of the states will be observed.
Bell states possess the property that measurement outcomes on the two qubits are correlated. As can be seen from the expression above, the two possible measurement outcomes are zero and one, both with probability of 50%. As a result, a measurement of the second qubit always gives the same result as the measurement of the first qubit.
Bell states can be used to quantify entanglement. Let m be the number of high-fidelity copies of a Bell state that can be produced using local operations and classical communication (LOCC
then maximally entangled has a value of 1).
Entanglement concentration
Pure states
Given n particles in the singlet state with a yield
have a Schmidt decomposition where coefficients p(x) form a probability distribution, and thus are positive valued and sum to unity
which are not part of any sequence which is likely to occur with high probability, known as the typical set
Then the fidelity
with which they can overcome the noise of a quantum channel to communicate successfully.
Universal entanglement concentration studies the case where the Schmidt coefficients of the input pure state are not assumed to be known. Matsumoto and Hayashi proposed a distortion-free universal protocol that achieves the entropy rate and produces an exact maximally entangled state when it succeeds.
Mixed states
.
Bell pairs which they share with high fidelity. What Alice and Bob have then effectively accomplished is having simulated a noiseless quantum channel using a noisy one, with the aid of local actions and classical communication.
be a general mixed state of two spin-1/2 through a noisy channel between Alice and Bob, which will be used to distill some pure entanglement. The fidelity of , represent the reduced density matrices for either particle. The following protocol is then used:
Performing a random bilateral rotation on each shared pair, choosing a random SU(2) The Werner state has the same purity F as the initial mixed state M from which it was derived due to the singlet's invariance under bilateral rotations.
while the components of the other three Bell states are equal.
states are then acted on by a bilateral XOR states; and it is discarded otherwise.
rotation, and made rotationally symmetric by a random bilateral rotation.
from a collection M. This method can then be combined with others to obtain an even higher yield.
Distillation protocols
BBPSSW protocol
The Bennet-Brassard–Popescu–Schumacher–Smolin–Wooters (BBPSSW) protocol is one of the simplest protocols that uses CNOT (Controlled-NOT) gates and measurements to probabilistically increase the entanglement of Bell states (standard maximally entangled two-qubit states). Here's a step-by-step example:
Setup:
.
closer to 1 through distillation.
Protocol steps:
CNOT operation: is addition modulo 2. This step correlates the two copies.
Measurement and postselection:-basis (measuring 0 or 1). If both measure same output (i.e., 0 or 1), they keep the control qubits and discard the targets; otherwise, they discard both pairs. This postselection step has a probability of success but increases the fidelity of the remaining entangled pair.
Example calculation:
was 0.6, the protocol can increase it to around 0.8 with some probability.
state.
DEJMPS protocol
The Deutsch–Ekert–Josza–Macchiavello–Popescu–Sanpera (DEJMPS) protocol is an optimized version of BBPSSW and works especially well for Bell diagonal states.
Setup: is the largest coefficient.
Protocol steps:
Apply local unitaries:.
CNOT operations: Similar to the BBPSSW protocol, Alice and Bob each apply a CNOT operation between their pairs.
Basis measurement: After the CNOT, Alice and Bob measure the target qubits in the Bell basis, postselecting on successful outcomes.
Example calculation:
.
Filtering protocol
Filtering protocols apply local filtering operations to probabilistically enhance entanglement without requiring multiple pairs. This approach is useful when operations are limited, such as in photon-based quantum communication.
Protocol steps:
.
.
. .
initially, filtering can increase the fidelity to 0.8 or higher, but it reduces the probability of obtaining this result due to the probabilistic nature of the filter.
Procrustean method
The Procrustean method of entanglement concentration can be used for as little as one partly entangled pair, being more efficient than the Schmidt projection method for entangling less than 5 pairs,) of the n pairs in advance. The method derives its name from Procrustes
, she can separate out particles which are more likely to be measured in the up/down basis, and left with particles in maximally mixed state of spin up and spin down. This treatment corresponds to a POVM (positive-operator-valued measurement). To obtain a perfectly entangled state of two particles, Alice informs Bob of the result of her generalized measurement while Bob doesn't measure his particle at all but instead discards his if Alice discards hers.
Stabilizer protocol
pure ebits noisy ebits. Two parties can then use the noiseless ebitss for quantum communication protocols.
The two parties establish a set of shared noisy ebits Bell states locally. She sends the second qubit of each pair over a noisy quantum channel rearranged so that all of Alice's qubits are on the left and all of Bob's qubits are on the right. The noisy quantum channel qubits noisy ebits acts on Alice's qubits is some Pauli operator acting on Bob's qubits.
A one-way stabilizer entanglement distillation protocol uses a stabilizer code quantum error-correcting code. The distillation procedure begins with Alice measuring projectors. The measurement commutes
The following important Bell-state matrix identity
projects Bob's qubits onto a subspace. Alice restores her qubits to the simultaneous +1-eigenspace. Bob combines his measurements with Alice's to determine a syndrome for the error. He performs a recovery operation on his qubits to reverse the error. He restores his qubits. Alice and Bob both perform the decoding unitary corresponding to stabilizer logical ebits physical ebitss.
Entanglement-assisted stabilizer code
Luo and Devetak provided a straightforward extension of the above protocol (Luo and Devetak 2007). Their method converts an entanglement-assisted stabilizer code into an entanglement-assisted entanglement distillation protocol.
Luo and Devetak form an entanglement distillation protocol that has entanglement assistance from a few noiseless ebits noiseless ebits noisy ebitss. The total state of the noisy and noiseless ebits identity matrix acting on Alice's qubits and the noisy Pauli operator qubits ebits ebitss only.
The protocol proceeds exactly as outlined in the previous section. The only difference is that Alice and Bob measure the generators in an entanglement-assisted stabilizer code qubits qubits are noiseless.
We comment on the yield of this entanglement-assisted entanglement distillation protocol. An entanglement-assisted code initial noiseless ebits.
Entanglement dilution
The reverse process of entanglement distillation is entanglement dilution, where large copies of the Bell state are converted into less entangled states using LOCC with high fidelity. The aim of the entanglement dilution process, then, is to saturate the inverse ratio of n to m, defined as the distillable entanglement.
Applications
Besides its important application in quantum communication, entanglement purification also plays a crucial role in error correction for quantum computation, because it can significantly increase the quality of logic operations between different qubits. The role of entanglement distillation is discussed briefly for the following applications.
Quantum error correction
connecting Alice and Bob.
In some cases, entanglement distillation may work when conventional quantum error-correction techniques fail. Entanglement distillation protocols are known which can produce a non-zero rate of transmission D(p) for channels which do not allow the transmission of quantum information due to the property that entanglement distillation protocols allow classical communication between parties as opposed to conventional error-correction which prohibits it.
Quantum cryptography
The concept of correlated measurement outcomes and entanglement is central to quantum key exchange, and therefore the ability to successfully perform entanglement distillation to obtain maximally entangled states is essential for quantum cryptography.
If an entangled pair of particles is shared between two parties, anyone intercepting either particle will alter the overall system, allowing their presence (and the amount of information they have gained) to be determined so long as the particles are in a maximally entangled state. Also, in order to share a secret key string, Alice and Bob must perform the techniques of privacy amplification and information reconciliation to distill a shared secret key string. Information reconciliation is error-correction over a public channel which reconciles errors between the correlated random classical bit strings shared by Alice and Bob while limiting the knowledge that a possible eavesdropper Eve can have about the shared keys. After information reconciliation is used to reconcile possible errors between the shared keys that Alice and Bob possess and limit the possible information Eve could have gained, the technique of privacy amplification is used to distill a smaller subset of bits maximizing Eve's uncertainty about the key.
Quantum teleportation
In quantum teleportation, a sender wishes to transmit an arbitrary quantum state of a particle to a possibly distant receiver. Quantum teleportation is able to achieve faithful transmission of quantum information by substituting classical communication and prior entanglement for a direct quantum channel. Using teleportation, an arbitrary unknown qubit can be faithfully transmitted via a pair of maximally-entangled qubits shared between sender and receiver, and a 2-bit classical message from the sender to the receiver. Quantum teleportation requires a noiseless quantum channel for sharing perfectly entangled particles, and therefore entanglement distillation satisfies this requirement by providing the noiseless quantum channel and maximally entangled qubits.
See also
Notes and references
.
.
.
Mark M. Wilde, "From Classical to Quantum Shannon Theory", arXiv:1106.1445.