arvau

Wikipedia / Polity data series

The Polity data series is a data series in political science research. Along with the V-Dem Democracy Indices project and The Economist Democracy Index, Polity is among prominent datasets that measure democracy and autocracy.

The Polity study was initiated in the late 1960s by Ted Robert Gurr and is now continued by Monty G. Marshall, one of Gurr's students. It was sponsored by the Political Instability Task Force (PITF) until February 2020. The PITF is funded by the Central Intelligence Agency.

The data series has been criticized for its methodology, Americentrism, and connections to the CIA. Seva Gunitsky, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto, stated that the data series was appropriate "for research that examines constraints on governing elites, but not for studying the expansion of suffrage over the nineteenth century".

Scoring chart

Polity score range

10

6 to 9

1 to 5

−5 to 0

−10 to −6

Regime type

Full Democracy

Democracy

Open Anocracy

Closed Anocracy

Autocracy

Polity Score ranges from -10 to +10

Scores for 2018

Country

Democracy score

Autocracy score

Polity IV score

Polity IV regime type

1

2

−1

Closed Anocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

3

1

2

Open Anocracy

2

4

−2

Closed Anocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

7

0

7

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

0

10

−10

Autocracy

0

6

−6

Autocracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

8

0

8

Democracy

7

0

7

Democracy

7

0

7

Democracy

7

0

7

Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

7

1

6

Democracy

2

3

−1

Closed Anocracy

0

4

−4

Closed Anocracy

1

5

−4

Closed Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

7

1

6

Democracy

1

3

−2

Closed Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

7

0

7

Democracy

0

3

−3

Closed Anocracy

Congo Brazzaville

0

4

−4

Closed Anocracy

Congo Kinshasa

1

4

−3

Closed Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

1

6

−5

Closed Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

3

0

3

Open Anocracy

8

1

7

Democracy

9

1

8

Democracy

6

1

5

Open Anocracy

0

4

−4

Closed Anocracy

8

0

8

Democracy

0

6

−6

Autocracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

3

2

1

Open Anocracy

4

0

4

Open Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

4

1

3

Open Anocracy

Gambia

4

0

4

Open Anocracy

8

1

7

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

1

8

Democracy

4

0

4

Open Anocracy

7

1

6

Democracy

8

1

7

Democracy

6

1

5

Open Anocracy

7

0

7

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

6

0

6

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

7

1

6

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

5

1

4

Open Anocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

2

5

−3

Closed Anocracy

0

6

−6

Autocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

8

0

8

Democracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

8

0

8

Democracy

6

0

6

Democracy

9

1

8

Democracy

8

1

7

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

6

0

6

Democracy

6

0

6

Democracy

7

0

7

Democracy

6

1

5

Open Anocracy

0

2

−2

Closed Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

1

5

−4

Closed Anocracy

6

1

5

Open Anocracy

8

0

8

Democracy

6

0

6

Democracy

8

1

7

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

7

1

6

Democracy

6

1

5

Open Anocracy

8

1

7

Democracy

0

10

−10

Autocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

0

8

−8

Autocracy

7

0

7

Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

5

0

5

Open Anocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

9

0

9

Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

0

10

−10

Autocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

5

1

4

Open Anocracy

0

3

−3

Closed Anocracy

0

10

−10

Autocracy

7

0

7

Democracy

9

1

8

Democracy

8

1

7

Democracy

2

4

−2

Closed Anocracy

Slovak Republic

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

9

1

8

Democracy

5

0

5

Open Anocracy

9

0

9

Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

7

1

6

Democracy

0

4

−4

Closed Anocracy

6

1

5

Open Anocracy

0

9

−9

Autocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

0

9

−9

Autocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

1

4

−3

Closed Anocracy

4

1

3

Open Anocracy

0

3

−3

Closed Anocracy

1

3

−2

Closed Anocracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

7

0

7

Democracy

0

4

−4

Closed Anocracy

0

8

−8

Autocracy

1

2

−1

Closed Anocracy

5

1

4

Open Anocracy

0

8

−8

Autocracy

8

0

8

Democracy

8

0

8

Democracy

10

0

10

Full Democracy

0

9

−9

Autocracy

1

4

−3

Closed Anocracy

0

7

−7

Autocracy

6

0

6

Democracy

5

1

4

Open Anocracy

Criticism

The 2002 paper "Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy" claimed several problems with commonly used democracy rankings, including Polity, opining that the criteria used to determine "democracy" were misleadingly narrow.

The Polity data series has been criticized by Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting for its methodology and determination of what is and isn't a democracy. FAIR has criticized the data series for Americentrism with the United States being shown as the only democracy in the world in 1842, being given a nine out of ten during slavery, and a ten out of ten during the Jim Crow era. The organization has also been critical of the data series for ignoring European colonialism in Africa and Asia with those areas being labeled as no data before the 1960s. FAIR has also been critical of the data series' connection to the Central Intelligence Agency. Max Roser, the founder of Our World in Data, stated that Polity IV was far from perfect and was concerned at the data series' connections with the Central Intelligence Agency.

Seva Gunitsky, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto, wrote in The Washington Post where he stated that "Polity IV measures might be appropriate for research that examines constraints on governing elites, but not for studying the expansion of suffrage over the nineteenth century". Gunitsky was critical of the data series for ignoring suffrage.

See also

References