Wikipedia / 1915 Manitoba general election
Wikipedia / 1915 Manitoba general election
The 1915 Manitoba general election was held August 6, 1915 to elect members of the Legislative Assembly of the Province of Manitoba, Canada. Liberals under Norris took a slight majority of votes and won a landslide majority in the Legislature. They replaced the Conservative government that had ruled the province since 1899 but had lost power after investigation for corruption.
This election was held only one year after the previous general election of 1914. In that election, the governing Conservatives of premier Rodmond Roblin were confirmed in office with 28 seats out of 49. In early 1915, a commission appointed by the Lieutenant Governor found the government guilty of corruption in the tending of contracts for new legislative buildings.
Roblin denied the charges, but resigned as premier on May 12. Three days later, the lieutenant-governor called upon Tobias Norris, leader of the official opposition Liberals, to form a new administration. The house was quickly adjourned, and new elections were scheduled for August.
The primary issue of the campaign was corruption of the Roblin government. The pro-Liberal Manitoba Free Press ran numerous articles criticizing the practices of the Roblin government, and alleging that the "Roblin machine" still controlled the Conservative Party.
Liberals claimed they would manage the province's affairs in a businesslike rather than a partisan manner, an approach typified by Provincial Treasurer Edward Brown call for the province to "forget party for five years and get down to business".
Female suffrage was an issue in the campaign. Norris's Liberals promised they would enact female adult suffrage if elected to office. Due to this, Nellie McClung, who had returned to Manitoba from her home in Alberta, campaigned on behalf of Liberal candidates. The government gave votes to women in 1916, becoming the first province in Canada where women could vote. (Treaty Indians were still barred from voting until 1952.) The Liberal party's platform also promised direct legislation and plebiscites on public issues.
The question of prohibition was an issue at the time. The Liberal Party promised to hold a provincial referendum on the question. A referendum was held on March 3, 1916, and a majority voted in favour.
Facing unpopularity due to the corruption scandal, the Manitoba Conservatives chose federal Member of Parliament (MP) James Albert Manning Aikins as their new leader on July 15. Aikins had never served in the Roblin government and was regarded by many as free from the controversy that had forced the Conservatives to resign. In a further effort to separate themselves from the Roblin government, the Conservative party tried to change its name, referring to itself as the "Independent-Liberal-Conservative" party for this election. Liberals ridiculed this name change and sarcastically described the "new" Conservatives as the "Purity Party". The "Independent-Liberal-Conservative" name seems to have been dropped shortly after the election.
The election results were a disaster for Conservatives. They won only five seats out of 47, and Aikins lost by a considerable margin in Brandon City. The Liberals under Norris won a landslide majority with 40 seats, the largest victory in Manitoba history, although with barely more than half the vote.
Labourites made advances in the legislature. In the Winnipeg Centre district, Fred Dixon was re-elected, this time as an independent candidate with support from both Liberals and the Labour Representation Committee. The Social Democratic Party also won its first seat in the province, electing Richard Rigg to one of the two seats in north-end Winnipeg. The other seat was taken by Solomon Hart Green, the first Jew to serve in the Manitoba Legislature.
For this election (like the previous one in 1914) Winnipeg was divided into three districts, each having used two members, with each seat being filled in separate contests.
The Manitoba francophone-dominated constituencies continued to support candidates of the Conservative party. Four of the five Conservative MLAs were from francophone areas. Many francophone voters opposed Norris's plans to end provincial funding for denominational Catholic schools. Many also opposed Norris's plans for Prohibition and equal suffrage.
This was the last election before Winnipeg was made into a single ten-seat district, and Single transferable voting was brought into use.
Electoral system
In this election Manitoba used a mixture of multi-member districts and single-member districts. In the multi-member districts - Winnipeg North, Winnipeg South and Winnipeg Centre - each member was elected in a separate contest through First past the post. There is little variance in the parties' vote tallies between the twin contests in each district.
In each single-member district the member was elected through First past the post.
Results
Riding results
(incumbent)John Williams (L) 815
W.S. Kenner (C) 632
John Wilton (L) 828
William Bayley (Labour Representation Committee) 773
(incumbent)John Thomas Haig (C) 590
William Wood (L) 1115
J. Harry Irwin (C) 918
(incumbent)George Malcolm (L) 873
S. Arnold (C) 422
Stephen Clement (L) 1914
James Albert Manning Aikins (C) 1213
Albert Prefontaine (C) 629
(incumbent)Thomas B. Molloy (L) 605
Andrew Myles (L) 851
(incumbent)George Steel (C) 789
William Harrington (L) 739
(incumbent)William Buchanan (C) 637
J.M. McQuay (Ind) 233
(incumbent)Robert Thornton (L) 1146
John C. Walker Reid (C) 851
Edward August (L) 1134
Andrew S. Argue (C) 848
Thomas Glendenning Hamilton (L) 2319
Donald Munro (C) 866
John David Baskerville (L) 1181
G. Coulter (C) 460
William Findlater (L) 1383
(incumbent)Sam Hughes (C) 792
Taras Ferley (L-Ind) 1172
(incumbent)Sveinn Thorvaldson (C) 562
(Einar Jonasson had been nominated as the official Liberal candidate, but withdrew.)
(incumbent)James Armstrong (L) 1154
A. Singleton (C) 484
(incumbent)James Breakey (L) 1091
John Perdue (C) 636
(incumbent)John Henry McConnell (L) 1063
J. Moss Fraser (C) 596
(incumbent)Aime Benard (C) 527
James H. Black (L) 400
George Prout (L) 1295
R. Sanders (C) 754
Samuel Hayden (L) 779
(incumbent)George Lawrence (C) 656
Charles Duncan McPherson (L) 863
(incumbent)John J. Garland (C) 700
(incumbent)Tobias Norris (L) 1334
W.J. Cundy (C) 592
Philippe Talbot (L) 713
(incumbent)Jean-Baptiste Lauzon (C) 558
George Thomas Armstrong (L) 1090
W.H. Sharpe (C) 1006
(incumbent)George Grierson (L) 1173
James Muir (C) 654
(incumbent)Valentine Winkler (L) 1180
William Johnston Tupper (C) 712
(incumbent)Jacques Parent (C) 740
William Molloy (L) 683
(incumbent)James Baird (L) 1331
John T. Dale (C) 419
(incumbent)John Graham (L) 933
Robert F. Lyons (C) 770
(incumbent)Ewan McPherson (L) 1065
Fawcett Taylor (C) 807
(incumbent)Frederic Newton (C) 714
William Angus (L) 609
Arthur Lobb (L) 1275
Thomas Scott (C) 639
William Wilber Wilfred Wilson (L) 1033
J.P. Laycock (C) 614
Joseph Dumas (L) 921
J.A. Beaupre (C) 790
J.P. Howden (Ind L) 640
(incumbent)Donald Ross (L/Ind) 1014
Thomas Hay (C) 489
Skuli Sigfusson (L) 1291
Paul Reykdal (C) 831
(incumbent)Joseph Hamelin (C) 443
Z.H. Rheaume (L) 414
A. McLeod (Ind) 266
(incumbent)William Sims (L) 626
Daniel D. McDonald (C) 414
George William McDonald (L) 687
(incumbent)James Johnson (C) 651
(incumbent)George Clingan (L) 1181
R.A. Knight (C) 772
Winnipeg
Winnipeg North "A":
Robert Newton Lowery (L) 2443
Arthur Beech (SDP) 2248
(incumbent)Joseph P. Foley (C) 1490
Winnipeg North "B":
Richard Rigg (SDP) 2494
Solomon Hart Green (L) 2263
E.R. Levinson (C) 1248
Winnipeg Centre "A":
(incumbent)Thomas Herman Johnson (L) 6763
A.J. Norquay (C) 2346
Winnipeg Centre "B":
(incumbent) Fred Dixon (Ind, formerly Lib-Lab MLA) 6443
H.M. Hanneson (C) 2048
George Armstrong (SPC) 804
Winnipeg South "A":
(incumbent)Albert Hudson (L) 5986
W.J. Boyd (C) 2011
Winnipeg South "B":
(incumbent)William Parrish (L) 5635
Lendrum McMeans (C) 2303
Deferred elections
The Pas, August 25, 1915:
Edward Brown (L) accl.
Horace Halcrow had been nominated by the Conservatives to contest this riding, but withdrew before the election. Halcrow had been Manitoba's chief game warden under the Roblin government.
Post-election changes
Rupertsland (new constituency), September 16, 1916:
John Morrison (Ind-L) accl.
Iberville (res. Aime Benard, 1917), November 1, 1917:
Arthur Boivin (C) elected
Roblin (res. Frederic Newton, 1917), November 19, 1917:
William Westwood (Ind-L) elected
Irwin L. Mitchell (L)
(A Winnipeg Free Press report from November 20, 1917 shows Westwood winning by 186 votes, with one poll yet to declare. This was likely the first provincial election where Manitoba women cast votes.)
Morris (dep. Jacques Parent, 1917; no by-election)
Minnedosa (George Grierson to cabinet, November 10, 1917), November 30, 1917:
George Grierson (L) elected
Winnipeg North "B" (res. Richard Rigg, 1917), January 15, 1918:
Robert Jacob (Union-L) 2923
E.R. Levinson (Ind) 2251
(Numbers taken from the Winnipeg Free Press.)
Rhineland (dec. Valentine Winkler, June 7, 1920; no by-election)
References